I submitted an offer from a buyer client on a property listed with a very respected company this past Wednesday. It was a low offer to be sure, but that is not uncommon. The property has been listed for quite a while; 250 days as a matter of fact. It is vacant and needs updating everywhere. The listing agent never acknowledged receipt until I called her Friday. She was less than enthusiastic. I didn't care. Get me an answer.
We spoke again today, and the answer was NO.
No counter offer, no attempt to negotiate, just "too low, try again." This is extremely foolish. It is the nature of buyers to come in low in this market; to take that personally is ill advised. Even if you are angered at a low offer, you count to 10 and negotiate. So guess what? My buyer is now unhappy.
It isn't terribly wise to antagonize buyers in this market when you haven't sold in 8 months. MLS records have this agent as having exactly 12 closings since January 1, 2007. It's no wonder. In speaking with her, I told her that I wished she had advised her people to make a counter offer. It would cost them nothing to do so. She said that it cost nothing to not make a counter either, but she seems to not grasp that it costs her client a possible sale.
I sent her an email of a listing I sold this past summer which had a lowball offer that my seller client wanted to outright deny. I told him to counter it and that I'd bring it home. A week later we had an accepted offer of $285,000 on a $299,000 listing when the initial offer was just 240. That's negotiation. We erred on the side of possibility.
The smart thing to do with any low offer, even one of 50 cents on the dollar (ours, for the record, was far higher), is to make a counter offer. The name of the game is dispassionate, business-like negotiation. That is what makes minds meet. Never say NO. You can't sell the property when you say no. Make a counter offer, even if it galls you. You might be very glad you did.
- We Are Westchester County, NY Real Estate. Reach Phil at (914) 723-8900.
- J. Philip Faranda, Broker-owner, J. Philip Real Estate, LLC. 2010 Vice President, Westchester-Putnam Multiple Listing Service.
- I am one of New York's premier short sale REALTORS.
- J. Philip Serves Briarcliff Manor, Ossining, Croton, the River Towns, Westchester County, and the bedroom counties of New York City.
- Free MLS Search! Register for a Free Listingbook account and search the MLS like an agent.
- I am hiring agents.
I dont get it either, too many agents stand in the way of negotiating a deal when the should be helping it.
Hi Phil-
We have successfully negotiated some pretty silly offers this past couple of years. I NEVER throw one out.
--Sara in San Antonio
Perhaps it was the Seller and not the Agent who chose to ignore your offer. I agree, a good Agent always encourages a counter offer. However, sometimes there are stubborn clients who simply don't want to budge. Their problem! Sometimes it's best to fire those clients!
Melinda,
I'm sure it was the seller. The agent is not advising them, she's just being a carrier pigeon. You have a break a sweat sometimes.
We just have to present all offers & try to help sellers understand that without the contract we have nothing to negotiate the sale of their home.
We should always advise the seller to counter. I actually witnessed an offer (not my seller or buyer) where the seller was offended by a low offer and to express their disapproval countered significantly above the original asking price. Hmmmm...wonder what that proved?
Joe- it proved why they remained unsold.
It is our job to present all offers. I am surprised at some agents who say they do not want to waste their time.
WOW! This agent needs to review why they are in the real estate business with an open mind. I had an offer on a property that was way too low and the seller countered with $25,000.00 above the listed price and what do you know the so called buyer countered with a full price offer. Contract Accepted. This was as Joe's example above but it turned out great. The buyer could have offered $15,000. under list to start with and that would have been accepted as well.